If you’re searching for roof replacement in Lake Mary, FL, choosing the right roofing company can make the difference between a stress-free project and a costly nightmare. Lake Mary homeowners need contractors who are licensed, experienced, and committed to quality workmanship, whether you’re replacing shingles after storm damage, upgrading to a stone-coated steel roof, or installing low slope roofing.
This guide compares the five best roofing companies in Lake Mary based on licensing, customer reviews, services offered, manufacturer certifications, warranty coverage, and overall reputation. From full roof replacements to emergency repairs, these contractors represent the most trusted names serving Lake Mary and greater Seminole County.
Whether you live in Lake Mary’s historic downtown, the newer developments off Lake Emma Road, or anywhere in between, this comparison will help you find the right roofing partner for your home.
Not all roofing contractors are created equal. Lake Mary homeowners should prioritize companies that meet these essential criteria:
Every legitimate roofing company in Florida must carry:
Never hire an unlicensed contractor. In Florida, unlicensed roofing is a felony, and you’ll have no legal recourse if something goes wrong.
Lake Mary’s climate demands roofing contractors who understand:
Look for companies with established roots in Central Florida, not fly-by-night storm chasers who disappear after hurricane season.
Certified installers from manufacturers like GAF, CertainTeed, Owens Corning, and Atlas offer:
Certification isn’t just a credential, it directly affects your roof’s warranty length and coverage.
Check multiple review platforms:
Pay attention to how companies respond to negative reviews, that tells you how they handle problems.
The best roofing companies in Lake Mary offer:
Specialization: Residential roof replacement, storm damage, insurance claims
Service Area: Lake Mary, Seminole County, Central Florida
Established: 2019
License: Florida CCC Licensed & Insured
Pinnacle Roofing Group has earned its position as Lake Mary’s top-rated roofing contractor by combining technical expertise, exceptional customer service, and transparent communication. Since 2019, they’ve built a reputation for treating every roof replacement like it’s their own home.
Comprehensive Roofing Solutions
Pinnacle handles all roofing types common in Lake Mary:
Whether you need a complete roof replacement, storm damage repairs, or preventive maintenance, Pinnacle provides expert solutions tailored to your home and budget.
Premium Installation Standards
Every Pinnacle roof replacement includes:
Elite Manufacturer Certifications
Pinnacle holds the highest tier certifications from major manufacturers:
These certifications unlock extended warranties, up to 50 years on qualifying systems—giving Lake Mary homeowners the best protection available.
Storm Damage & Insurance Expertise
Lake Mary experiences severe weather annually. Pinnacle’s team includes HAAG Certified Inspectors who:
Transparent Communication
Pinnacle’s customer service consistently earns five star reviews. Every project includes:
The 400+ Review Difference
Pinnacle Roofing Group has earned over 400 five-star reviews across Google, Facebook, and the Better Business Bureau—more verified customer feedback than any other Lake Mary roofing contractor. They maintain a 4.9/5 Google rating and A+ BBB accreditation.
Services Offered:
Certifications & Credentials:
Warranty Coverage:
Financing: Multiple options including:
Response Time:
What Sets Pinnacle Apart:
Customer Reviews: 4.9/5 stars (400+ Google reviews, A+ BBB rating)
Contact Information:
📞 (386) 631-5566
🌐 pinnacleroofinggroup.com
📍 Serving Lake Mary, Seminole County, and Central Florida
Specialization: Residential and commercial roofing
Service Area: Central Florida
Established: 1970s
Schick Roofing brings over four decades of experience to Central Florida’s roofing market. As one of the area’s longest-established contractors, they’ve built a reputation for reliability and professional service.
Strengths:
Services: Shingle roofs, tile roofs, flat roofing systems, roof repairs, commercial roofing, re-roofing
Coverage: Lake Mary and broader Central Florida region
Schick’s longevity in the market and capacity to handle large-scale projects make them a solid choice for Lake Mary homeowners seeking an established contractor.
Specialization: Residential roofing and insurance claims
Service Area: Seminole, Orange, Volusia Counties
Established: Early 2000s
All County Roofing serves homeowners across multiple Central Florida counties with a particular focus on storm damage response and insurance claim assistance.
Strengths:
Services: Roof replacements, repairs, storm damage assessment, insurance claims, shingle and tile installation
Coverage: Lake Mary, Sanford, Longwood, Orlando, DeLand, and surrounding areas
All County’s insurance claim experience and multi-county coverage make them particularly useful for homeowners dealing with storm damage across multiple properties or complex insurance situations.
Specialization: Residential roof replacement
Service Area: Greater Orlando area
Established: 1990s
Central Florida Roofing operates throughout the greater Orlando metropolitan area including Lake Mary, providing traditional residential roofing services.
Strengths:
Services: Asphalt shingle installation, tile roofs, metal roofing, roof repairs, re-roofing
Coverage: Lake Mary and greater Orlando metropolitan region
Central Florida Roofing delivers standard residential roofing services backed by decades of local market experience.
Specialization: Residential roofing services
Service Area: Seminole County
Established: 2010s
Legacy Roofing focuses on residential projects throughout Seminole County with a local, personalized approach to roofing services.
Strengths:
Services: Roof replacements, repairs, inspections, shingle and tile installation
Coverage: Lake Mary, Sanford, Longwood, Altamonte Springs, Winter Springs
Legacy provides localized residential roofing services with a Seminole County focus and community-oriented approach.
Once you’ve narrowed your options, use these comparison factors to make your final decision:
About Credentials:
About The Project:
About Materials & Installation:
About Communication & Support:
| Factor | Why It Matters | What to Look For |
|---|---|---|
| License & Insurance | Legal protection and quality assurance | Active CCC license, current insurance certificates, willingness to provide documentation |
| Manufacturer Certifications | Extends warranty coverage significantly | GAF Master Elite, Atlas Diamond, CertainTeed Select ShingleMaster, or equivalent |
| Review Volume & Quality | Indicates consistent performance | 100+ reviews, 4.5+ stars, responsive to feedback |
| Local Experience | Understanding of Florida climate and codes | 5+ years in Central Florida, familiar with Seminole County permitting |
| Underlayment Standard | Major factor in roof longevity | Peel-and-stick as standard (not felt, not an upgrade) |
| Workmanship Warranty | Protection against installation defects | Lifetime warranty, transferable, written documentation |
| Communication Style | Reduces stress during project | Dedicated project manager, progress updates, responsive to calls/texts |
| Storm Response | Critical in Florida | Emergency tarping available, insurance documentation expertise |
| Financing Options | Makes quality roofing accessible | 0% APR options, flexible terms, same-day approval |
| Cleanup Standards | Protects your property and landscaping | Magnetic sweeps, catch-all systems, final walkthrough |
Roof replacement costs in Lake Mary typically range from $8,000 to $75,000 for most single-family homes, depending on:
Get 3-5 written estimates from licensed contractors. Be cautious of quotes significantly below market, proper installation with quality materials and correct methods has real costs. The cheapest bid often becomes the most expensive mistake.
Installation timeline: 1-3 days for most single-family homes
Full project timeline breakdown:
Factors that affect timeline:
From contract to completion: 2-3 weeks for shingle roofs, 8-12 weeks for tile roofs
The best roofing material depends on your budget, home style, and long-term plans:
Architectural Shingles (Most Popular)
Tile Roofs
Metal Roofing
You need a full replacement if:
Repairs might be sufficient if:
Get a professional inspection. Reputable contractors like Pinnacle Roofing Group offer free inspections and will honestly tell you whether you need replacement or if repairs will suffice. Be wary of contractors who always recommend replacement, sometimes repairs are the right answer.
Insurance typically covers roof replacement when:
Insurance typically does NOT cover:
Important for Lake Mary homeowners:
Work with a roofing contractor experienced in insurance claims. Companies like Pinnacle Roofing Group have HAAG-certified inspectors who document damage properly and work directly with adjusters to maximize your coverage.
Verify in 3 easy steps:
Check for:
Also verify insurance:
Never hire an unlicensed contractor. In Florida, unlicensed roofing is a third-degree felony. If something goes wrong, you have no legal recourse and your homeowner’s insurance may not cover damages.
Choosing a roofing contractor is one of the most important decisions you’ll make as a homeowner. Your roof protects everything inside your home, your family, your possessions, your investment.
The five companies listed in this guide represent Lake Mary’s most trusted and capable roofing contractors. Each brings different strengths: decades of experience, insurance expertise, local focus, or specialized certifications.
For Lake Mary homeowners seeking the highest quality workmanship, strongest warranties, and best customer service, Pinnacle Roofing Group stands apart. Their triple manufacturer certifications (Atlas Diamond, GAF Master Elite, CertainTeed Select ShingleMaster), 400+ five-star reviews, and standard use of premium materials like peel-and-stick underlayment, not as an upsell, but on every job, deliver exceptional value.
Whether you need a complete roof replacement, emergency storm repairs, or help navigating an insurance claim, Pinnacle’s team provides expert guidance and quality installation that protects your Lake Mary home for decades.
Ready to get started?
📞 Call Pinnacle Roofing Group at (386) 631-5566
🌐 Visit pinnacleroofinggroup.com
📅 Schedule your free inspection and estimate today
Serving Lake Mary, Seminole County, and Central Florida with honest roofing solutions since 2019.
Justin Coltharp is the Founder and Roofing Contractor at Pinnacle Roofing Group, a Central Florida roofing company built on integrity, transparency, and hands on craftsmanship. As a State Certified Roofing Contractor (CCC1332542), Atlas Diamond Select Contractor, and CertainTeed Silver Star Contractor, Justin brings expertise that fewer than 2% of roofers nationwide can match. With over 3,000 roofs installed and a 4.9 star rating backed by 450+ verified reviews, he personally reviews every roof and oversees every project: because your home deserves an owner who shows up, not one who disappears after the sale.
